This post is inspired by a recent client session where we investigated an argument that was somewhat typical between my client (let’s call her Jane) and her partner.
The biggest difficulty for Jane was the awful feeling of having “nowhere to go” in a tense situation like that. It brought back a similar hurt she had suffered in her past and it was very painful very quickly for her.
How logic can box us in
The tension between partners snowballed and nothing seemed to help much to dissolve it.
It was difficult for Jane to even imagine that anything could actually work in this kind of situation. What with how her partner typically behaved and the sense of powerlessness that arose in Jane in response.
Jane could only see things not working out in the future and she had very detailed, logical reasons to think that.
Things get derailed in specific ways
Now you see, for a communication trainer, it’s relatively easy to see where conversation gets derailed.
In this case, one of the problems I could see was that Jane was guided by an “obvious”, logical thought that her partner “doesn’t need to worry”.
The thought was logical and completely understandable.
The elements of the situation were indeed such that Jane was tracking things, had good reasons to act the way she did and her actions were considerate.
Except that communicating that logic, by saying not to fuss, didn’t work. Jane’s partner only got more upset in response.
The blind spot of logical thinking
The logical thinking, obvious as it was to Jane, didn’t work. It didn’t land as helpful with her partner. In fact, expecting that the logic SHOULD work was part of the problem.
It’s very understandable that we think logic or facts should take care of things. It’s the FALSE but persistent impression we pick up from school and societal conditioning.
If only the other person has the correct facts, they will act the way it’s logical that they should, right?
But when was the last time you saw somebody drop the feeling of worry just because you thought or said that they don’t need to worry???
No, human beings are not logical in that way.
A different kind of logic
But there IS rhyme and reason in the way conflicts arise and get resolved.
We tense up and argue when we are scared about our needs not getting met and we return to calm and connection when we see that our needs matter.
In Jane’s case, we created a chart to help her track the DEEPER logic in her couple arguments: to clarify what each partner was feeling and what they were needing.
So that she could see where the situation COULD go next and so that those steps were about providing for the needs that arose between both partners.
The components of deeper understanding
When Jane filled in the chart to help her see the WHOLE picture, not just what seemed logical to her at first, she could see quite easily what might be better to do or say in that kind of argument.
She discovered her way of navigating beyond the place of “nowhere to go” and it involved using the heart and the gut in addition to tracking her thinking.
If you find yourself stuck in a situation with nowhere to go, you can hope that the other person will do the “right”, logical thing or you can pause to regroup and get the whole picture. A better picture of what’s going on will give you a better idea where to go next.
You are welcome to use stick figures and add elements in like in the cartoon above. Or, if it’s easier for you, just jot them down in a table format like so:

Enjoy filling in the blanks!


