
I notice that when I’m learning a new skill, when it’s important I get good at the new thing, I have two priorities:
1. To get sufficient encouragement to keep going despite the inevitable discomfort and setbacks.
2. To get doable, personalised pointers so that I can improve faster.
What this means is that learning a skill is about repeated practice AND feedback.
But feedback giving and receiving is a vulnerable thing and something that most people don’t learn as a skill. Often, even if there is an opportunity for receiving feedback, what we get is not very useful.
What type of feedback is not that useful
I’ve summarised the three unskillful ways to give feedback I’ve experienced on the receiving end, i.e these are behaviours to avoid, as acronym N.O.T
N = NICENESS. Avoid words giving only vague value e.g “You came across as a confident person”. This may be encouraging in the moment but gives little clue as to how that effect was created or could be recreated, i.e little learning.
O = OPINIONS. Avoid saying what you THINK because that says more about you and reveals little about the learner’s impact, eg. “It’s interesting”. The learner needs to get specific references about them to improve their skill.
T = TRADITIONAL TEACHER-LIKE TALK. e.g “Too long”. Short comments on what’s “wrong” can be dispiriting and are hardly usable to the recipient. It leaves more questions than it answered: “too long why?” “how long is too long” etc.
Of course this doesn’t mean that people who give that kind of feedback are unhelpful. They just don’t know how to support you better.
The good news is that you can role model feedback requesting and so both get better return information for your learning and support others to give/receive better feedback.
What type of feedback is easier to give and more useful
The world right now could use more feedback that supports the recipient to do better and to want to do better, don’t you think?
I’ve summarised what I see as the four key aspects of quality feedback with an acronym F.E.E.D
F = FRIENDLY, warm tone. Feedback is about supporting learning and learning doesn’t happen in the atmosphere of criticism. Rather, it happens where there is openness and warmth so please use any words, emoticons, tone or gesture that place you as a friend rather than clever clogs. <3
E = EXACTLY WHAT AFFECTED YOU? What stood out and was connecting (or not)? Which words? Which choice? Without knowing what exactly created the impact it created, the learner may not get you and can’t improve. e.g “You were looking directly at me, at the camera, and this helped me feel connected to you”.
E = EXPRESS WHY THIS MATTERS TO YOU. Why is it relevant or significant to you? Without a personal (rather than preachy) why, it’s harder to understand or care about your comments. e.g “I’m a visual learner so when you showed that card with a mnemonic, it helped me relax and get it”.
D = DO’S i.e suggestions for future impact (as in “do’s and don’ts”, but stick to do’s). Specifically say:
i) what to continue doing that works well (if the person asked for encouragement)
ii) what to do differently (if they asked for suggestions or you have reason to believe they’d welcome suggestions).
Only do’s, as don’ts can create tension and are less usable. e.g compare:
“Don’t worry about some viewers disliking your video.”
vs
“You can assume that there ARE those who resonate with your offering and will appreciate your confidence of putting it across because I did. I’d like to encourage you to think about the viewers who get you and speak to them as you record your video.”
With feedback, giving is also receiving
Finally, know that if you give feedback to fellow students on the same course, you’re simultaneously teaching yourself.
As you articulate what worked or didn’t work for you on the receiving end, you’re making notes for your own attempts in the future.
It really pays to be generous with requesting and giving feedback.
To summarise, skilled feedback is not delivering vague opinions but offering a caring gift of specific observations towards the person’s learning.
In that form, it’s a blessing.
Where could you use it in your life? What do you want to get better at and how can you get feedback again and again?


